Ghost Lake (2004) 3.7/10⭐ Straight-to-Video Movie Review For $110,000 it's G-r-e-a-t!
Ghost Lake (2004)
Straight-to-Video Movie Review
![]() |
This was made for $110,000 and for that alone, it's great! If you think of this as a mediocre episode from a '90's TV series, you'll like it a whole lot more...
3.7 out of 10 stars ⭐ Time to read: 4-5 min
BASIC PLOT:
Rebecca Halster has been a primary caregiver for her disabled and deteriorating father for quite awhile. She hasn't been out of the house, for several months, and her parents basically push her out the door, telling her to have a good time. But while Rebecca is relieving some stress, her parents die in a tragic gas leak. She is struck with survivor's guilt, and becomes passively suicidal. She decides to return to the only place she ever felt happiness, the family's summer cottage on Rushford Lake. On the way, her suicidal ideations take hold, and she attempts to crash her car, nearly missing a pedestrian. It's late at night, raining, and she blames the conditions on nearly running the man down. His name is Stan James, and he lives just a few cabins over. She agrees to give him a ride, but then forgets to drop him off. They have a moment, two damaged people who recognize the scars in one another. They start seeing a lot of each other, but Rebecca's survivor's guilt won't allow her to get to close to Stan. Besides that, strange things are happening at the lake. First, Rebecca begins having prophetic dreams. Then she begins seeing tragedies that no one else sees. Will Rebecca be able to untangle the secrets of Rushford Lake before they pull her under, into the abyss?
(The whole review and comments are graded on a low-budget curve)
![]() |
| Tatum Adair as Rebecca Halster |
![]() |
| Rebecca blames herself for her parents death |
WHAT WORKS:
*THE SEX SCENE AT THE BEGINNING REALLY WORKED It was shot well, and was titillating. It was also realistic. After reading the other reviews, I know this is a hard concept for some men to understand, but women are sexual creatures, with needs, the same as men. Rebecca's mother tells her to go "have some fun" because Rebecca is one of the primary caregivers of her disabled father. She's sacrificing her own life to help take care of him, putting everything else on hold. She hasn't been out of the house, she's stressed, and has been pent up in more ways than one. She needs stress relief, and that DOESN'T MAKE HER A SLUT!
*PRECOGNITIVE DREAMS ABOUT THE ARTIFICIALLY FLOODED LAKE ARE GOOD FORESHADOWING It gives the audience a reason to believe Rebecca when she sees things no one else sees. She mentions later, she was given medication to help with her visions, but clearly she just possesses the gift of foresight. Rebecca dreams of true events she has no foreknowledge of, which means the audience should trust her.
![]() |
| Many viewers wished for more about the underwater town. It could have been used as an atmospheric character, a real missed opportunity. |
*THE SETTING WAS WELL CHOSEN The lake houses were both creepy, but somehow comforting. The movie worked well as an atmospheric, but more time should have been utilized to set the scene, make the setting a character in it's own right.
![]() |
| The beautiful setting was under utilized.... |
![]() |
| ...but there were some great shots. |
*SOME OF THE CHARACTERS ARE WELL CAST The two main characters, Rebecca & Stan (Tatum Adair & Timothy Prind) are very good low-budget actors. I never doubted they were who they said were, two damaged people who found each other. Many of the ancillary characters were also well cast, like the a-hole fisherman played by Damian Maffei. He was successful as the jackass fisherman, who runs Rebecca off of his private dock. Also, his face is very creepy when transformed into a corpse. Another success was Chuck Franklin as Dr. Bloch (named after Robert Bloch, the writer of Psycho I presume), who played the crazy coroner. He provided some needed comic relief, as the wacky medical examiner.
![]() |
| Chuck Franklin as Dr. Bloch gave some much needed comic relief. |
![]() |
| Rebecca & Stan are well cast as damaged people who find each other |
*FOR THE BUDGET AND THE ERA, THE SPECIAL EFFECTS WERE TOP NOTCH I thoroughly enjoyed the campy throwback special effects. If you're of a certain age, these special effects will probably make you feel nostalgic. There were a myriad of different types too. Some were genuinely unsettling, some were throwbacks to '50's horror films, but all worked.
![]() |
| The special effects were all over the place! |
![]() |
| Some of the effects are campy... |
![]() |
| ...some are literally gross |
*STAN'S LOOK IS PERFECTION Stan is the perfect "Mr. Sensitive Ponytail Man" of the '90's. He has all the prerequisites: Henley shirt, braided hemp necklace with one bead, stonewashed jeans and a ponytail! It could be a Halloween costume it's so cliché (it's also why the audience is pissed at his fate).
![]() |
| Stan's look is clichéd perfection. He's literally the '90's Mr. Sensitive Ponytail Man (shout out to the movie, Singles) |
*THE UNUSUAL STORY BOTH WORKED AND WAS THE MOVIE'S DOWNFALL This movie felt like it should have been the plot of a '90's horror TV mini-series, so the layers of the plot could have had enough time to be unfolded and explained properly. The premise was good, the execution was confusing.
WHAT DOESN'T WORK:
*THE SCREEN SPLITTING WAS TERRIBLE! This is not an episode of 24, what were you thinking?! I agreed with the reviewer who said it felt more like a new editor playing with unfamiliar software, than an actual artistic choice.
![]() |
| WTH was Jay Woelfel thinking?! |
*SOME OF THE DIALOG IS OFF There are several conversations that don't ring true. Stan's diatribe about friends and lovers isn't believable, and there's other dialog that falls flat too, like Rebecca's first encounter with the sheriff.
![]() |
| Stan's "friends & lovers" diatribe is ridiculous! |
*SOME OF THE CASTING IS BAD Sheriff Dobbs looks the part, which I'm sure is why he was cast, but Gregory Lee Kenyon can't act his way out of a paper bag. Azure Sky Decker (the twins) was fine when she was playing off another actor, but could not pull off the scene when her twin convinces her to go to the water. It should have been reshot.
![]() |
| Azure Sky Decker did a decent job, except for one scene |
![]() |
| Gregory Lee Kenyon is terrible in this movie! |
*THE MAIN REASON WHY THE MOVIE FAILS IS THE TERRIBLE ENDING The ending betrays the audience. It is clear how this movie should end - with redemption for everyone! Throughout the movie, there is repeated visual foreshadowing, using images of the unified couple, facing the upcoming struggles TOGETHER. They've both previously been loners, but now they have each other, and the ending betrays this visual foreshadowing.
![]() |
| Stan & Rebecca were meant to finish this journey TOGETHER! I'm sure this is why the ratings are so low! |
![]() |
| All of these visual foreshadows tell the audience the couple will persevere. It's a betrayal of the audience to kill Stan, especially at the hands of Rebecca's doubts. |
Stan is an abuse victim, who finally stood up to his abuser, his father. Unfortunately, while defending himself, Stan killed his father. He, like Rebecca, has been racked with survivor's guilt, and has also been suicidal. This is NOT a character who should be sacrificed! I guarantee if Stan had lived, the rating of this movie would NOT be 2.6, but probably closer to 4.3. Rebecca needs to feel redeemed, and you don't get that outcome from not trusting your own instincts. Throughout the whole movie, Rebecca does trust herself, believing what she sees, even when no one else does. Then she is validated when the paranormal happenstances are revealed to be true. Why change that direction, and have her suddenly doubt her own intuition about Stan? It interrupts the flow of the film. Rebecca's doubts effectively get Stan killed, instantly making Rebecca less likable, and ruining the end of the movie. It also doesn't help that the ending they do use is totally cheesy and nonsensical.
![]() |
| Stan & Rebecca have both been suicidal, yet they help each other... |
![]() |
| .... you don't destroy that by having Rebecca give into her doubts. |
Also, there are several references to both Stan and Rebecca being suicidal. Delving into that more would have given an emotional edge to the characters, and the story. It bonds them together, giving the couple and the audience something to fight for. The final scene should have shown Stan, Rebecca and the little girl standing in the cemetery. They all have someone there, and all need closure. The visual of the traditional nuclear family (even though the little girl doesn't belong to them) standing in front of a grave, as the camera moves upward, would have upped the enjoyment quotient and the rating of this film, for a great many people. (Remember the cardinal rule in filmmaking-Wow them at the end and all mistakes are forgiven!)
![]() |
| Without Stan, there is no ending that doesn't piss the viewer off... |
*MOST OF THE OTHER REVIEWERS ARE JUDGEMENTAL ASSHOLES WITH TIK-TOK BRAINS First of all, let me say this-I'm appalled at all the slut shaming in the IMDb reviews, reviewer Claudio Carvalho literally calls Rebecca a "slut, having sex with two strangers.. while grieving the death of her parents." First of all, one isn't a stranger, and two, if this behavior was coming from a man, it would be getting high fives. movieman_kev, thegrimsleeper-1 & hevhighwaywoman say the same thing. I'm totally disgusted with this type of misogyny. Second, it seems like some of the reviewers didn't even watch the movie close enough to review it. They commented that the father crawled when he smelled gas instead of just walking, not realizing he was in a wheelchair, and had to crawl. Second, they lamented the father wouldn't have been woken up by the smell of gas, missing that he was already awake when he smelled it. If you didn't watch the movie closely, please don't review it.
Also, I hate to be a snob and point this out, but the reviews that are well written and thoughtful generally "get this" movie, and the Tik-Tokers who have burned up their brains watching short form content, don't get it. This movie feels like it's adapted from a book, another reviewer commented it was the plot of the novel, "Beneath Still Waters" by Matthew Costello. But after reading the synopsis, it doesn't really have that many similarities. However, I agree with another reviewer that said it had the potential to be Stephen King-esq, but dropped the ball. I'm really trying to say that it will appeal more to people with an attention span, who are readers, than to horror fanboys. It's a thriller, and should not be in the horror category AT ALL.
![]() |
| I'm amazed that slut shaming is still a thing, and this type of misogyny still exists. |
TO RECOMMEND OR NOT TO RECOMMEND, THAT IS THE QUESTION:
Do I think this is going to be for everybody? ABSOLUTELY NOT! There 's enough cheesy effects, and dreadful acting to fill the Sargento/Porno Con, but that was the fun of it, and to me, the story was interesting/unusual enough to overlook a lot of things I wouldn't normally let go.
So ask yourself, does bad acting and silly special effects bother you? Or are they part of the charm? Can you overlook a lot, if the story is fun/interesting/engaging? If it's something you've never seen before, does that give it a boost? Only you can answer those questions, and decide for yourself. Like I said, I would have rated it 4.5-4.7 if Stan hadn't been killed needlessly. But for most people, I think this would get a 3.
Personal note: I love watching a singular, artistic vision. This is all Jay Woelfel from start to finish. He wrote it, directed it, edited it, scored it, wrote a crappy song for it, even starred in it. Watching someone's artistic vision is a little like reading their diary, and for that type of sharing, I think it's a success.
-Blondiee10 (aka Vans - Vanessa Hooper
(I appreciate your opinions and comments about the review, it helps me understand other viewers)
![]() |
| Look for the shadowy stranger, it's really the writer/director |
![]() |
| Interesting visuals |
CLOSING NOTES:
*THIS IS A STRAIGHT-TO-VIDEO MOVIE, please keep that in mind before you watch/rate it. Straight-to-video movies have a much lower budget, and so you expectations should be adjusted.
![]() |
| Certain special effects are nostalgic |
![]() |
| Not sure what the bouncing green ball represents |
![]() |
| Cool, old 1960's Tarot deck |
*I HAVE NO CONNECTION TO THE FILM, or production in ANY way. I'm not writing this as a favor, or because I was paid.
*CERTIFIED HUMAN WRITTEN REVIEW This review was NOT written in full, or in part, by a bot. I am just an honest viewer, who wishes for more straight forward reviews (less trolls and fanboys), and better entertainment. Hope I helped you out.





























Comments
Post a Comment
I invite commentary, I love friendly debate